Global Programme of Action Coalition for the Gulf of Maine (GPAC)

1998 Action Plan

1. The Gulf of Maine

The Gulf of Maine stretches from the north shore of Cape Cod, Massachusetts in the United States to Cape Sable, Nova Scotia in Canada, and extends 200 miles offshore to the rich underwater plateaus of the Georges and Browns Banks. Three states and two provinces border the Gulf - Massachusetts, New Hampshire, and Maine in the United States; New Brunswick and Nova Scotia in Canada. The Gulf encompasses six bays, including the Bay of Fundy. The rivers draining to the Gulf of Maine have a combined watershed area of over 69,115 square miles (165,185 square kilometers). The Gulf of Maine is a shared, public resource of world class ecological, cultural, economic, scientific and intrinsic value. Through the concerted effort of many individuals and organizations we have compiled a large body of knowledge of the physical, chemical and biological interactive processes that together create the Gulf Region environments. However, it is becoming increasingly clear that the marine environments of the Gulf of Maine are vulnerable to damage and to loss. Sustaining the environmental and economic viability of the Gulf of Maine poses a major challenge to science, business and communities. To meet this challenge we need to validate our existing knowledge base, share experience, harmonize management approaches, build on our successes and explore new opportunities to integrate all these activities across disciplines, sectors, communities and countries.

If we are to sustainably manage the resources of the Gulf, we must ask and answer important questions on the fate and effect of pollutants and the alteration and loss of critical habitats in these marine environments.

2. The United Nations Global Programme of Action for the Protection of the Marine Environment from Land Based Activities (the GPA)

The GPA is intended to provide guidance on developing a process for management actions that result in sustainable use of coastal and marine resources. Degradation of the marine environment results from human activities that use resources beyond replenishment, that dispose of wastes in areas unable to assimilate pollutants, and that alter habitats through siltation, sedimentation, removal, filling and other disturbances. These activities not only threaten resources, but in many cases may imperil human health through contaminated seafood, unsafe beaches and waters for swimming and other recreational activities.

The GPA provides a process for developing programs of action that can be used by all countries; those which are highly industrialized and those with developing economies. Although first described in Chapter II, entitled Actions at the National Level, the process is applicable to regional, national and more local areas. The GPA methodology has six recommended steps:

3. Commission for Environmental Cooperation (CEC)

In 1996 Canada, Mexico and the United States were among the 109 nations signatory to the Global Programme of Action (GPA) for the Protection of the Marine Environment from Land Based Activities. The Commission for Environmental Cooperation (CEC) is assisting these three North American countries in implementation of the GPA through the establishment of cooperative partnerships. Currently the CEC Cooperation on the Protection of Marine and Coastal Area Ecosystems Project supports initiatives in two bi-nationally shared marine environments: the Bight of the Californias (United States and Mexico), and the Gulf of Maine (United States and Canada). The Gulf of Maine Pilot Project is being executed by the newly formed working group—the Global Programme of Action Coalition for the Gulf of Maine (GPAC).

4. The Global Programme of Action Coalition for the Gulf of Maine (GPAC)

The Global Programme of Action Coalition for the Gulf of Maine (GPAC) is a bi-national working group comprised of some forty individuals representing federal and state/provincial governments, the research sector, the private sector, non-government organizations, communities and First Nations. Formed in 1997, the GPAC meets regularly and has developed an Action Plan to guide its initiatives in 1998-1999. The primary goal of the GPAC is to establish a collaborative, short-term organization dedicated entirely to the implementation of the United Nations Global Programme of Action for the Protection of the Marine Environment from Land-based Activities in this region.

5. Implementing the GPA in the Gulf of Maine

The GPAC recognizes and respects the roles and contributions of the Gulf of Maine Council, and other organizations, in advancing environmental stewardship in this region. In addition to shared interests, the GPAC also shares a number of members with the Gulf of Maine Council Working Group, and relies on these linkages to assist in building a productive partnership between these two organizations. The GPAC has identified specific Gulf of Maine Council objectives as identified in the Gulf of Maine Council Action Plan: 1996-2001 as appropriate to the principles and objectives of the United Nations Global Programme of Action (Attachment A).

The GPAC will work to ensure that where possible and appropriate, work undertaken by the GPAC builds on these, and other, regional policies, protocols, priorities and programs of action for both the development and implementation of the GPAC Action Plan.

6. 1998 GPAC Action Plan

The 1998 GPAC Action Plan focuses on the relationships between land-based activities and their effects on the sustainability of marine and coastal habitats of the Region. Relying heavily on the methodology framework developed by the GPA, the GPAC Action Plan has been organized as a logical, step-wise process based on five major stages, similar in context and scope to the first five steps of the GPA itself.

Stage One: Strategic assessment of pollutants and habitats in the Gulf of Maine
Stage Two: Establishment of priority pollutants and critical habitats
Stage Three: Identification of management objectives for priority problems
Stage Four: Identification, evaluation and selection of strategies and measures, including  management approaches
Stage Five: Adoption of criteria for evaluating the effectiveness of proposed strategies and programs

Development and implementation of the GPAC Action Plan will respond to the following objectives:

  • strategic identification, synthesis and integration of existing work in the Gulf of Maine to reduce overlap and needless repetition of effort;
  • cross-sectoral, multi-disciplinary consensus on the identification and ranking of significant habitat issues and toxic contaminants in the region
  • integrated collaborative partnering with existing institutions, organizations, communities and the private sector that are already at work in environmental management in the region, or can be encouraged to participate,
  • the ultimate integration of GPAC activities and resources into existing, more permanent organizations once the Action Plan to advance the GPA is in place.

6. 1  Stage One:    Strategic Assessment of Pollutants and Habitats in the Gulf of Maine

GPAC Objective:     Stage One of the GPAC Action Plan will identify and assess current knowledge on the marine and coastal habitats of the Gulf of Maine and the existing and potential effects of pollutants from land-based activities on the sustainability of these habitats.

GPAC Actions:     The GPAC will contract with experienced researchers in Canada and the United States for the research and production of two Scoping Papers, one on Pollutants in the Gulf of Maine, one on Marine and Coastal Habitats in the Gulf of Maine. These papers will be the result of a combination of the researcher’s personal expertise, comprehensive reviews of the published and unpublished literature, and interviews with key individuals from the science community, government agencies, the private sector, community organizations, and First Nations.

Each of the Scoping Papers will be a comprehensive document and will include an annotated bibliography and list of contributing organizations and individuals.

An executive summary will be prepared for each paper and provided to the GPAC for circulation to Members. The Executive Summaries and Scoping Papers will be used as the background documents and primary references for GPAC Members. The Scoping exercise will assist the GPAC in the development of technical programs and the identification of invited speakers and participants to an interactive, priority-setting Workshop.

Structure:     The GPAC will establish a Habitat and a Pollutants Task Group whose duties and responsibilities will include managing the Contractors for the Scoping Papers, and assisting the GPAC with the development of the technical program for the proposed Workshop.

6.2  Stage Two:    Priority Setting – Workshop #1

GPAC Objective:     Stage Two of the Action Plan will organize an interactive workshop of multidisciplinary and cross-sectoral participants to review the findings of the Scoping Papers, to establish criteria (filters) for priority setting and to identify the priority pollutants and critical habitats in the Gulf of Maine requiring immediate action.

GPAC Actions:     The GPAC will establish a Workshop Task Group for the Workshop to address all aspects of logistics and operations. The Workshop Task Group will work closely with the Habitat and Pollutants Task Groups to develop the technical program and to identify appropriate speakers and facilitators. The Task Group will address tasks such as:

Venue:     Saint John Hilton, Saint John, New Brunswick. April 27 -29, 1998

Workshop Program:

Format:      Approximately 100 persons selected for maximum interaction between sectors and disciplines.

6.3  Stage Three:     Identification of management objectives for priority issues

GPAC Objective:     Stage Three will identify and assess the potential of existing programs and     activities in the Region to address issues related to the management of priority pollutants and critical habitats identified during Workshop #1.

GPAC Actions:     The GPAC will further investigate potential near-term demonstration projects identified at Workshop #1 that represent issues of binational interest, are financially and operationally feasible, and provide experience useful to other parts of the region. Such projects could serve to demonstrate progress in addressing a specific pollutant or habitat issue and attract additional resources for implementation.

The GPAC Habitat and Pollutants Task Groups will contract with experienced researchers in Canada and the United States for the research and production of two additional Scoping Papers to address the following:

As with the first Scoping Papers, these documents will synthesize the researcher’s personal expertise, comprehensive reviews of the published and unpublished literature, and interviews with key individuals from the science community, government agencies, the private sector, community organizations, and First Nations. The relevant sectors/sources would also be surveyed about knowledge of programs in other regions that would be helpful in thinking about action plans

Each of the Scoping Papers will be a comprehensive document and will include an annotated bibliography; and list of contributing organizations and individuals.

An executive summary will be prepared for each paper and provided to the GPAC for circulation to Members. The Executive Summaries and Scoping Papers will be used as the background documents and primary references for GPAC Members. The Scoping exercise will assist the GPAC in the development of technical programs and the identification of invited speakers and participants to a Workshop intended to define further actions to reduce priority pollutants in the Gulf of Maine and to protect and sustainably manage critical habitats.

Structure:     The GPAC Habitat and Pollutants Task Groups will manage the Contractors for the Scoping Papers, and assist the GPAC with the development of the technical program for the proposed Workshop #2.

Format:    Approximately 100 persons selected for maximum interaction between sectors and disciplines.

6.4  Stage Four:   Action Plans – Workshop #2

GPAC Objective:    Stage Four of the Action Plan will organize an interactive workshop of multidisciplinary and cross-sectoral participants to assess the adequacy of existing programs and activities intended to reduce pollutants and protect and manage habitat in the Gulf of Maine. Workshop Participants will review the findings of the second Scoping Papers, and identify opportunities for the GPAC to respond to priority issues with immediate action.

GPAC Actions:    The GPAC Workshop Task Group membership will change in accordance with the location of the proposed Workshop. The Workshop Task Group will continue to work closely with the Steering Task Groups to develop the technical program for Workshop #2, and to identify appropriate speakers and facilitators. Facilitators from Workshop #1 will be continued, as appropriate. The Task Group will address tasks such as:

Venue:     At a location to be announced in the New England (GOM) States.

Workshop Program:

Format:    Approximately 100 persons selected for maximum interaction between sectors and disciplines. Continuity of participants from Workshop #1 will be encouraged.

6.5  Stage Five:  Follow up on GPAC Action Plan

The strength of the GPAC is clearly vested in the participation of individuals representing many organizations in both countries. Through the mobilization of the resources represented by GPAC members the Coalition will be able to advance the initiatives of the proposed GPAC Action Plan much further than would ordinarily be possible if the CEC was the only support available.

However, if GPAC is to be effective, efficient and relevant in the implementation of its Action Plan, there needs to be a reliable process of project review, assessment and adjustment. This process should respond to verifiable criteria to measure success, be initiated during Workshop #2, and include identification of support for ongoing initiatives of the GPAC.

Schedule:     Early 1999

7. GPAC Task Groups

The GPAC has established five Task Groups to guide and manage specific elements of the Action Plan. To allow for broader representation and participation, the GPAC Task Groups may include individuals other than GPAC members. The Task Groups established to date include:

7.1  Pollutants Task Group
7.2  Habitats Task Group

These two Task Groups will direct the development of the Terms of Reference, identification and contracting of researchers, and the technical review of both Scoping Papers. These Task Groups will also assist the Workshop Task Group in the development of the Technical Programs for the proposed Workshops.

7.3  Workshop Task Group

The Workshop Task Group will be responsible for the organization of the proposed 1998 Workshops, including all logistics associated with Workshop venues, schedules, and activities. The Task Group is formed for Workshop #1, but may add or delete members as appropriate to Workshop locations and planning requirements.

7.4 Communications Task Group

The Communications Task Group will be mobilized more fully in 1998 and will be responsible for the following activities:

7.5   Endowment Fund Task Group

The Endowment Fund Task Group will examine the potential for the establishment of a $1 million ($US) charitable trust to assist communities in their efforts to study, manage and protect critical coastal and marine habitats in the Gulf of Maine. Monies raised for and directed to the Fund will be held and ethically invested by a community foundation. The disbursement of monies from the fund will be guided by a Task Group comprised of representatives of citizen's organizations from around the Gulf. The majority of disbursed funds will directly support the acquisition, management or protection of critical wildlife habitat in the Gulf by citizen's organizations. Strategic targeting of priority habitats will be achieved with input from groups around the Gulf. A list of proposed activities for the Endowment Fund Task Group is included as Attachment B.

The GPAC will evaluate the potential for success of this activity based on the findings of the Task Group.

8.  Proposed Action Plan Schedule for 1997-1998-1999

TASK

ACTION

DATE

Establishment of GPAC Implementation Task Groups Identify and invite GPAC Members and others to participate in specific Task Groups. November 1997
  Initiate development of Terms of Reference for Scoping Papers November 1997
  Identify authors and contract Scoping Papers December 1997
Development of 1998 GPAC Action plan Development of the draft 1998 Action Plan 30 November 1997
  Review and comments on the draft Action Plan 9 January 1998
  Incorporation of comments 16 January 1998
Convene third Meeting of the GPAC – Halifax NS Update action plan, review Executive Summaries, advance plans for Workshop #1 10-11 March 1998
  The GPAC Liaison will prepare minutes of Third meeting 20 March 1998
Convene Fourth Meeting of the GPAC – Saint John, NB - WORKSHOP #1 Review Workshop Deliverables and GPAC Action Plan 28-31 April 1998
Convene Fifth Meeting of the GPAC – TBA Review Progress to date, advance plans for Workshop #2 July 1998
  The GPAC Liaison will prepare minutes of Fifth meeting July 1998
Convene Sixth Meeting of the GPAC – US Location - WORKSHOP #2 Review Workshop Deliverables and GPAC Action Plan Fall 1998
  The GPAC Liaison will prepare minutes of Sixth meeting Fall 1998
Convene Seventh Meeting of the GPAC – TBA Review and assess performance of GPAC Action Plan. Identify new mechanisms for advancement. Early 1999
  The GPAC Liaison will prepare minutes of Seventh meeting Early 1999

Attachment A

The Gulf of Maine Council on the Marine Environment

The Gulf of Maine Council was established by the governments of Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Brunswick and Nova Scotia to discuss and act upon environmental issues of common concern in the Gulf of Maine. Its mission is:

"To maintain and enhance environmental quality in the Gulf of Maine and to allow for sustainable resource use by existing and future generations.."

The Council is comprised of representatives of the Governor's and Premier's of these States and Provinces, and has identified four primary roles in its focus on the health of the Gulf of Maine:

                   1.     convene partners
                   2.     marshal resources and decide how best they should be used to further the Council's mission
                   3.     support project, when possible, as part of a region-wide focus
                   4.     educate the public and raise awareness of the value of the Gulf of Maine.

The Working Group of the Council consists of one person appointed by each Council member and one co-chair from each of the Council Committees. The Working Group provides support to the Council as follows:

The Gulf of Maine Council has constituted four Committees, whose members are appointed by the Working Group from a geographically balanced constituency of interested parties. The Gulf of Maine Committees include:

The Council has collaborated with six federal agencies (Environment Canada; the Department of Fisheries and Oceans; the U.S. Fish an Wildlife Service; the U.S. Army Core of Engineers; the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the National Ocean and Atmospheric Administration), as well as public and private entities, to develop the Gulf of Maine Action Plan (1996-2001). The Action Plan identifies five major goals:

Several operating criteria guide the Council in its development and implementation of the Action Plan. They include:

The GPAC has identified specific Gulf of Maine Council objectives as identified in the Gulf of Maine Council Action Plan: 1996-2001 as appropriate to the principles and objectives of the United Nations Global Programme of Action). They include:

Action 1:     Conduct a Gulf-wide reconnaissance and review of existing data and information on the Gulf of Maine Council's priority coastal species.

Action 2:     Convene the region's coastal habitat experts to assess the synthesis and develop recommendations on the most expedient and efficient methods for obtaining required information to improve management of these areas.

  • Gulf of Maine Council Strategy #1-3-1:    Conduct a Gulf reconnaissance to document rate of loss of regionally significant coastal habitats.

Action 1.     Assess the priority issues/activities affecting coastal habitats (e.g. land use, land-based sources of pollution, waste disposal, marine construction activities including harvesting, marine recreation, etc.) determine the level of threat (demographics, economics, land use changes), the rate of loss, and the immediacy of need for action.

Action 1. ...     convene a regional forum of ecosystem and public health managers, researchers and others as appropriate with expertise on toxic contaminants to identify the region's toxic contaminant priorities and the research required to implement appropriate management strategies.

Action 3.     Determine the appropriate actions, including education, regulation, and remediation, to manage the risks identified.

  • Gulf of Maine Action Plan Strategy #3-2-2:    Support the reduction of priority toxic contaminants entering the Gulf of Maine.

Action 3.     Develop and support implementation of a point source strategy that will meet or be below effluent limits for priority toxic contaminants.

Action 4.     Develop and support a strategy to use best management practices to address non-point sources contributing priority toxic substances.

Attachment B

Proposed Activities for the Endowment Fund Task Group

In 1998, the GPAC Endowment Fund Task Group will: